The titan of print, Encyclopedia Britannica is still around but only as a website now, it even has a chatbot (No thank you) and it tells me that “Expressionism is a 20th-century artistic movement where creators prioritize showing inner emotional experiences and psychological moods over depicting a realistic physical world.” I mean that could also be the very definition of fanzines right..Even better the EB goes on to say that “Artists distort shapes, use rough brushwork, and apply intense, unnatural colors to spark strong feelings like anxiety, fear, or raw passion.” I mean come on, that covers about 95% of the writing in some issues!!
Perhaps the purest form of “fanzine expressionism” were letters, remember them? Long gone are the days when we would sit and pour our heart out in biro (or fountain pen if you were feeling fancy) onto the page before putting all that into an envelope, affixing a stamp and wandering off down to the post box in the hope that days, weeks or even months later your innermost thoughts would receive some form of reply, privately in the same form or even via the pages of a fanzine!
So this week we will look at the ins and outs of this strange archaic practice and look at how this form of expressionism was used and abused therein.
No Fixed Abode
I mean we have to start with something that is probably actually more abstract that expressionist but its a cracker. This “letter” appeared in Hibernian’s Mass Hibsteria issue 81 in 1998. There’s not much to say really, it’s stupidly brilliant, filled some space and has me laughing 28 years later.

You could probably write a book about the joyous rampages through ‘literature’ in Mass Hibsteria, the place where Irvine Welsh made his literary debut. It would later incorporate Hibs Monthly and if you have the time there are 53 issues in the Scottish National Library spanning 1993 – 2004 (there were about 96 issues printed in all)
Not Big or Clever
Staying with spoofs for now, Stockport’s The Tea Party was always likely to include a mad idea by editor Dave Espley expanded into letter form and sent off to some organisation or other. In turn they would gracefully and dutifully reply not being aware that they had been done like a kipper. Prank shows like Impractical Jokers, Punk’d, and Candid Camera had nothing on Dave.
In this edition from issue 25 from May 1993 he suggests that Manchester based Piccadilly radio should furnish the needs of exiles with reporters at matches not just around the city but also at “fairly local” teams as well. John Pickford was clearly a very patient man. Piccadilly and Key 103 were in general superb local broadcasters with the sort of coverage and style we can only dream of nowadays. They went on to become Hits radio…need I say more.

Lets stay with The Tea Party but switch gears to more serious matters and letters. Kevin Francis was and still is a club legend at Edgeley Park and in issue 34 of TTP in 1994 Dave used letters in an altogether more serious way, this time to complain about Greater Manchester Radio allowing Paddy Crerand to air utter nonsense unchecked.

This carried on for 4 pages and demonstrates very well the depth of feeling fans have and the lengths we would go to just 30 years ago to express those feelings. Fanzines as “slow” social media.
The first letter copied to the fanzine is incredible in it’s depth and breadth, statements of fact are backed up with stats, there is a heartwarming anecdote about Kev’ interacting with young fans and even if it does lean into spurious comparisons with Eric Cantona the points about the way players would come up through the divisions in those days is excellent anda great record of footballing history. It is magnificent and incredible to think that someone went to these lengths. Nowadays it would just be a series of “Paddy Crerand is a W⚓︎” posts on X. Even better though is that Dave has lost the last part of the letter and the author’s name and has to apologise to him for this. PEAK FANZINE!

Crerand would apologise as the letter from GMR attests, fan power worked. The second letter makes a point that Roy Keane would repeat in 2014, Crerand only has eyes for one team. Crerand left local media to host 252 episodes of a heavily biased phone in show on MUTV, pulled one time when he went too far in criticising Dan Roan for breaking what he said was a crap story about Louis Van Gaal being sacked after the FA Cup final. Louis Van Gaal was duly sacked after winning the FA Cup. It’s refreshing to see that big clubs like United don’t have unbalanced, clickbait loudmouths shouting their cause nowadays…
Zombie Apocalypse
Fanzines covered history in a number of ways, and this piece from Ipswich fanzine Those Were The Days issue 81 in 2006 captured the result one of the stranger episodes in the clubs history. During an incredible 1980–81 season the club were chasing the incredible treble of the League, FA Cup, and UEFA Cup (ultimately “only” winning the UEFA Cup). Robson grew frustrated with what he felt was the subdued atmosphere at Portman Road and went to the press labeling quiet home supporters “a bunch of zombies” for not generating enough noise or passion to inspire the players.
Michael Sadler’s dad wrote to Bobby to complain and received this typically polite and apologetic reply. As you would, Mr Sadler senior kept this for 26 years and his son had it published in the fanzine.

TWTD might well have run this again in 2010 when Roy Keane repeated Robson’s criticism complaining of “moaning and groaning” supporters at Portman Road, an episode largely forgotten in favour of his famous prawn sandwich brigade jibe of 2000. Those Were The Days ran for 20 years before going online in 2010 explaining that “Over the last year we’ve found it increasingly hard to find the time to put zines together with the final issue, number 99, coming out before Christmas. The website and other commitments have taken up an increasingly large amount of time and in line with most similar paper-based fanzine, sales have dropped in recent years to around 1,000, about one-fifteenth of the website’s current daily unique users.” Pesky bloody internet.
Get The Abbey Rabbit
Many fanzines incurred the wrath of club secretaries or the chairman. Cambridge classic The Abbey Rabbit managed to do this with issue 1 with the common refrain of “It’ll hurt programme sales” being used. So Dave Filce and Nigel Pearce, the co creators wrote this excellent and quite lengthy letter to the club secretary.

Once again we have a great piece of social history and a great explainer of what fanzines were, how many there were and what they were about, basically what fans wanted in the 80s.
Though there was never a written reply from the club, this interesting explainer appeared along with the letter. It seems the club secretary was not just worried about programme sales but was wanting to nip in the bud anything like the campaign organised previously at Arsenal by a newsletter against Don Howe..A real eye opener as to the way club secretaries operate.

As the board meeting had passed without sanction The Abby Rabbit did indeed get down to business and by issue 4 in October 1988 they were happy to report that they had been matchball sponsors for a game against Halifax, oh the glamour.

Fishing, Norway and Len Ashurst
So goes the caption I assigned to this letter when I put it in the vaults. It appeared in issue 4 of Sunderland classic A Love Supreme in the spring of 1989.
It describes the quite incredible lengths that Steve went to to listen to Sunderland in the semi final of the Milk cup in 1985 and the consequence of of Sunderland’s victory for his finances. He segues seamlessly from that to his utter disdain for Len Ashurst, a man who played 458 times for Sunderland, second in the all time appearances list in Sunderland’s history, and one of only two outfield players to top 400 appearances. Still, he lost the Milk Cup final so…to be fair to Steve Sunderland were dreadful that season and were also relegated..Thankfully by now Steve lives in Kent so when Sunderland made it to Wembley again for the 1990 Play Off final I assume it cost him less even if he was probably calling for the dismissal of Denis Smith after a 1-0 reverse to Swindon.

Combined with the Wendell of Wearside fanzine seller special this page is everything you could wish from a fanzine. I’m glad they did but you do sometimes look at letters/pages like this and wonder if the editor looked and though, that’s it, we’ve peaked, nothing will get better than this and just stop.
Final Whistle
This all seems odd now doesn’t it, pre internet days when we had the time and energy to spend valuable minutes to put pen to paper and even more incredibly, get a coherent reply. As with all things fanzine their use was humorous, chaotic, mischievous, provocative, sometimes serious but most of all an important treasure trove of first hand lived experiences from decades ago.
I have and will keep pushing this point, a fantastic social history of an entire generation are recorded in print within the pages of fanzines, it is an underused and poorly curated resource that needs to be looked at more often. Plus they are a great source of humour!
As of this morning you can pick up a complete set of the 1973 US Print Encyclopedia Britannica on ebay for £186.58, 24 volumes with bookcase..collection only!



Leave a Reply