This week I was down the smoke again to listen to an excellent Seb White1 interview with author and Nutmeg editor Daniel Gray about his brilliant book, Fanzine. As I’ve said before I can’t recommend this book enough, it is an extraordinary collection of interviews with and the stories of many of the people central to the explosion of football fanzines from 1985 to 1995.

There will be a post of the full interview on Seb’s YouTube channel but in the meantime I’m going to summarise some of the conversation here. This isn’t a review of the book, there are plenty of other more capable people doing that and this blog in no way goes close to covering the contents of the book either so you have no excuse for not buying it. This blog is just some of the things I heard during the conversation and some of this, the questions in particular, are paraphrased..writing notes on an iphone whilst juggling a couple of pints is not the easiest thing to do.. In addition I’ve added some bits of background info myself based on my collection/research. Even at that I’m not sure I’ve covered even half of what was discussed.

Before we start, many thanks to the superb venue The Volley for hosting, https://thevolleylondon.com/ absolutely rammed with great scarves, pictures, stickers and of course screens to watch games.

Dan’s own story starts when a fanzine flew over his the head when thrown down the Holgate end at Ayresome Park as Gary Parkinson missed a penalty. In the ensuing scramble of “young supporters in ski jackets” a“grubby, creased copy of Fly Me To The Moon“ would become his. His dad would religiously buy him the programme but the fanzine was off limits so this chance meeting was a real boon. We carried an interview with the legendary FMTTM editor Rob Shrug quite some time ago, you can relive it here. https://footballfanzineculture.blog/2025/05/08/meet-the-editor-fly-me-to-the-moon/

It would be years before Dan plucked up the courage to write for FMTTM, but it became his matchweek ritual to read it, totally in awe of it and it’s creators and finally he dared to write a piece about the spelling of Middlesbrough and Teesside. (I checked these about 6 times before I published this article) The moment Dan opened the fanzine in the Ayresome pub and saw his piece set him on the road to being a writer.

My collection of FMTTM doesn’t extend to that article but I did find a couple including this one from issue 403 on season ticket renewal and his belief in Steve Gibson. In it Dan inadvertently accuses ‘boro fans of using ladies of the night but he recovers well and please note the correct spelling of Teesside.

Where did the idea for the book come from? “Bloomsbury wanted to do a coffee table book with lots of the great covers and illustrations from the time. This was the original plan but then Covid came and paper got much more expensive! Skip forward a couple of years and the Voice of the Fans exhibition at Leeds City Library came along and demonstrated the huge level of interest in the topic and so we revised the plans to what we have now, the story told by the protagonists”

Is there something that stands out for you in the interviews? “Yes, the humility of fanzine editors. They were just doing this to give fans a voice” Dan continued saying “The fanzines I still have and those in the When Saturday Comes archive made me realise how spiky, concise, poignant and great the writing was in fanzines. It really is all there about what it means to be a football fan.“

Dan went on to describe the humility and honesty of all of the editors and contributors who replied. People still just want to put their side of the story but in the context that they were just one of the many voices that shouted out at the time “I had a huge strike rate in getting replies, about 95% compared to the usual of about 50% when researching books”

Why did you narrow the scope of the book to 1985-1995 “It just seemed like a natural block of time, starting with the Bradford fire, running through the terrible disasters after that and covering the period when fanzine growth really peaked” Dan explained the potent nature of some of the writing in that period “The City Gent writing from the time in particular is a real stand out about what it out meant and felt like to be a fan”

Strangely enough Dan mentioned that there was little in the way of writing about Heyshel but as we’ve discovered, the real explosion in fanzine growth didn’t happen until a couple of years after 1985 (see https://footballfanzineculture.blog/2026/07/16/the-list-statto-edition-ii/ )

What strikes you about fanzines in this period? Aside from the terrible way fans were treated Dan also mentioned that “The rise of the modern game and the protests about Sky were very strong. The way fanzines offered an alternative view from the happy clappy nonsense we were fed and the hysteria over Italia 90” The resistance to Sky and generally cultural resistance to how fans were portrayed was very strong….“none of this was in the mainstream media and my perceptions of the 90s changed”. Dan also mentioned how much the media stole from fanzines, even in this period “by 95 fanzines were being crushed by the weight of celeb fans” Dan also mentioned the many links to music and fashion and the way many fanzines devoted their paltry profits to clubs, something you can find all about on these pages in a variety of blogs.

Are fans more tribal now? “Fanzines certainly weren’t, they published lists and reviews of other zines for example” Unfortunately as we all know, tribalism does work for clickbait. Dan went on “the unity around ID cards should be a lesson to people nowadays about the lack of unity, there are always ideas worth fighting for”

Is there a print renaissance going on? “Not sure and it’s not totally robust but I know we need to get away from screens more and talk, as fanzine editors did”

Are podcasts a replacement for fanzines? “Not really, they focus too much on being professional or boring team tactics” I’d add that podcasts tend not to be a forthright with their views on clubs, partly for legal reasons but sometimes to keep “in” with clubs. Fanzines in general didn’t worry about this.

What were your favourite titles? “oooh this is tough but let’s go with Dial M for Merthyr, great pun, great fanzine then and Dundee United fanzine called Can I Bring My Dog? named after the 1993 question a fan posed to the supporters club about the coach trip to an away Uefa cup tie with Brøndby in Denmark and finally War Of The Monster Trucks named after the programme ITV showed, a recording from 1990, instead of Sheffield Wednesday receiving the league cup and celebrating with the fans in 1991″

There was a question about an issue of the legendary Meadowbank Thistle fanzine AWOL “Written in a haze of alcohol and only lightly edited before publication” and a very naughty article they wrote about shoplifting in Edinburgh. Dan confirmed this was true. I have a copy of the article from issue 6 and it is included here for your delight. It is not a joke by the way, it’s an actual guide and will feature in an upcoming blog about fanzines and run-ins with the law

There was a question about the lowest club in the pyramid that ran a fanzine…we think in the pyramid it would be The Shrimpers at Harwich and Parkeston..we have covered that here. https://footballfanzineculture.blog/2026/01/15/meet-the-editor-shrimpers-review/HOWEVER we have also discovered 5 pub teams that ran fanzines for more than a few issues and that has now obviously given me an idea for a blog..

The evening ran away far too quickly, there was a great story involving Rupert Lowe and Hitler but I’m not repeating that here for obvious reasons. I was going to ask Dan who he would like to play him in the film of the book but that will have to wait for another time…

The Final Whistle

In the introduction to his book Dan writes “I wanted to write..primarily to salute and celebrate the fanzine movement and its vast, explosive contribution to fandom in the UK”. Boy does he succeed “Fanzines really gave a voice to the true fan, this is how I feel, this is what I still see on the terraces, not in the press box” Powerful stuff and a book you must own.

  1. https://youtu.be/ctiUQ74poIo?si=H6CF4pWNzyXII6z0 ↩︎

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.